Blogs: Richi Jennings
Date: November 16, 2011

Remember yesterday’s article about the employer that asked its departing employee to give it back “his” Twitter account? Here’s the ex-employee’s side of the story…

As you may recall, this employer -- PhoneDog Media (PDM) – wants its ex-employee – Noah Kravitz – to hand over the password to his Twitter account, and pay damages of $2.50 per month for each of its 17,000 followers. The eight months between the end of the employment and the lawsuit make a total of $340,000.

Below is my Q&A exchange with Kravitz, with only minor edits and reformatting:

Q:  Did you have a contract or informal agreement with PDM about ownership of your Twitter account or its followers?
A:  The agreement was that the account, which I created, was mine. My last day at PhoneDog was…October 15, 2010. On…October 18…they ran my “farewell post,” which I had…submitted before my last day. The post tells people they can follow me @noahkravitz. …Why would they point readers to the account, handle change and all, if they didn’t concur that the account was mine? …At the time I left, our relationship was good – or so I thought.

Q:  So why was the account named @PhoneDog_Noah?
A:  It’s named that way because when I created the account, PhoneDog was the only place I was publishing content.

Q:  Did you create the account, or did PDM (as it implies in the complaint)?
A:  I created it.

Q:  Are you open to some sort of compromise agreement or out-of-court settlement with PDM?
A:  I’m fortunate to have a great legal representation in Cary Kletter and his team at Kletter Law…but I did, and still, would love to work this all out of the court. … [T]he last thing anybody wants is to burden our public agencies unnecessarily.

Q:  What advice do you have for employees who are Tweeting partially on behalf of their employers?
A:  I’d advise employees to ask their employers for contracts, employee handbooks, and other legally binding company policy documents regarding Twitter, social media, and anything else they might be concerned about. …I never imagined they’d now be suing me for in excess of a quarter of a million dollars over my Twitter account. …So do everything you can to have a great working relationship with your employers…but make sure you protect yourself…it’s well worth it to cover everything you can by way of…your contract and looking into amending it whenever you fell necessary.

Q:  Are there any facts in my article that you want to clarify?
A:  PhoneDog alleges in their lawsuit that they asked me for the account and I said No. They never did. …The only time they “asked for the account” was when they served me with a lawsuit on a Sunday night during the summer of 2011.

[Kravitz also alleges that PDM owes him money, so there may be more to the story than a simple dispute over who owns some Twitter followers.]

Kletter + Nguyen Law LLP - San Mateo
1900 S. Norfolk Street, Suite 350
San Mateo, CA 94403
Phone: 650.577.2336

Kletter + Nguyen Law LLP - San Francisco
201 Spear Street, Suite 1100
San Francisco, CA 94105
Phone: 415.434.3400 
*By appointment only